Dolphin beaching puts Navy on defensive about sonar technology
When more
than 70 dolphins beached themselves in the Middle Keys
in March, leaving well
over half their number dead, there was one immediate suspect:
a U.S. Navy submarine conducting
exercises off the Keys in the days before the marine mammals
came to shore.
The USS
Philadelphia used mid- and high-frequency sonar at least
some of that time to navigate -
a fact that piqued the interest of marine mammal experts
and other scientists who believe that
powerful sonar transmissions from Navy submarines and
ships may harm dolphins and whales in ways
not yet understood. Nearly
two months later, investigators from the National
Oceanic
and Atmospheric Administration
are still conducting tests that may show whether sonar
was responsible. And a few biologists who
performed necropsies on some of the animals observed heart
and lung problems that may not be
indicative of harm from sonar. Sonar - "sound navigation
and ranging'' - is an apparatus that
transmits sound waves through water and uses echoes from
undersea terrain or solid objects in the
water to determine distance and movement.
"We
haven't ruled anything out. We are in the process
of compiling results,'' said Laura Engleby,
a NOAA Fisheries biologist involved in the stranding
response.
What
remains are tantalizing questions - and another high-profile
incident that has raised awareness
about sonar technology and placed its patron, the
Navy, on the defensive.
"I
think many scientists are becoming increasingly concerned
with this coincidence of stranding
in time and space with the use of naval sonars,''
said Andrew J. Read, a Duke University professor
considered a leading expert on the subject of sonar
and dolphins. "This is one of those human
activities that is rising to the top of our concerns.''
After
surfacing Feb. 28, the nuclear-powered submarine used
mid-frequency active sonar about 39 nautical
miles from Marathon, Fla., to navigate for about
21 minutes. On three other days, Feb. 27, March
1 and
March 2, when it was farther away, the sub used
high-frequency sonar, the Navy said. The dolphins
are
believed to have begun beaching March 2.
Marine
mammal strandings are fairly common, prompted by anything
from algae blooms to a single, sick
animal. Six weeks before the Keys stranding,
about 35 whales of three species stranded off
North
Carolina.
Though the Navy was conducting sonar exercises
nearby, the cause of the deaths in that case
has not yet
been determined.
Marine
mammals have their own highly developed "sonar''
systems of echo-location "clicks''
- used for
everything from finding a mate to procuring
a meal.
Humans
hear sound frequencies up to 20 kilohertz, the highest
pitch most babies can process.
Frequencies above that are called ultrasonic.
Some dolphins, whose inner ear is encased
in a
separate bone, have a range about five times
higher.
Some
scientists believe ships' sonar may disorient or scare
marine mammals, causing
them to surface
too quickly and creating the equivalent
of what divers know as the bends, nitrogen
bubbles
forming
in
tissue because of sudden decompression.
There
are three types of sonar: low-frequency, which travels
the farthest and is often
used for search
and surveillance; mid-frequency, commonly
used in training; and high-frequency,
which is the
weakest.
The exact ranges of military sonars,
which emit individual "pings'' lasting
a few
seconds, are classified.
The distance a sonar ping travels is
shaped by water temperature, salinity,
topography
and the
presence
of other objects in its path.
The
more powerful, low-frequency sonar has drawn the most
fire from groups
such as
the Natural
Resources
Defense Council, which sued the U.S.
military in 2002 to limit its use.
"Sonar
kills whales,'' said Michael Jasny, a senior policy
consultant
for the council.
"What
we've
seen
from recent events is that sonar
seems to be responsible in the deaths
of
more marine
mammal
species than
had earlier been supposed.''
Navy scientists - who argue that
the science is still unfolding -
don't
agree.
"Until
you know what the effects are, everything is speculation,''
said Frank
Stone, head
of marine mammal
research and development for the
chief of naval operations.
The
Navy is the largest sponsor of studies on marine mammal
responses
to sonar,
spending about
$10 million
a
year on the topic.
The
most conclusive link between the use of military sonar
and
injury to
marine
mammals was observed
from
a stranding of beaked whales
in 2000 in the Bahamas. The
Navy
later acknowledged
that
sonar likely
contributed
to the stranding of the extremely
shy species.
"We
basically herded the mammals into a boxed canyon
and they
couldn't escape
the
sound
of the sonar
and so
they beached themselves,''
said Rear Adm. Steven Tomaszeski,
oceanographer of the
Navy. "In
our investigation
of this, we did find out
that in the case of the
beaked
whale, it
does
seem very
susceptible to
mid-frequency sonar.''
Military
sonar has also been alleged as a factor
in the
strandings of porpoises
off the coast
of Washington
state
and
of melon-headed whales
off the coast of Hawaii,
while
other
potentially sonar-related
strandings have occurred
in
Greece and the Canary
Islands.
While
a NOAA report recently released on the Washington
porpoise deaths
left open
the possibility
that
sonar played
a part, the report was
largely inconclusive,
saying that
decomposition of the
animals made pinpointing
the exact
cause of death impossible.
Though
sonar can produce signs of physical damage,
like bleeding
in
and around
acoustic tissue,
some experts
wonder
whether sonar-induced
behavioral changes
might occur in some
cases.
"Sound
is the most important sense for
these animals,
and one of the
big issues
now that
people are struggling
with is whether the impacts that have
been documented
have been
a direct
result of
the sound - basically
damage
to the tissues - or
has the sound created
a behavioral
reaction that caused
damage,'' said
Trevor Spradlin,
a NOAA
biologist.
The
U.S. government has fought to protect
the
military's ability
to train with
active sonar
in the face of
mounting
international criticism
from groups such as
the International
Whaling
Commission, which
last year
issued a report
linking sonar and whale
deaths.
Among
the military's main concerns is a new
class
of stealthy,
easier-to-obtain diesel-electric
submarines believed
to be possessed by countries
such as North Korea
and Iran.
The
Navy has commissioned and conducted a number
of studies
aimed at gauging
the effect
of particular
levels of sound
exposure, some of
it from sonar, on
the hearing
of marine mammals.
The
research has shown
that some whales
experience
what's called a "temporary
threshold shift" in
hearing, a change
that fades within
minutes,
depending
on how
far away
the animal is from
a single sonar emission,
said Mardi
Hastings, program
officer
for marine mammal
science
and
technology at the
Office of Naval Research.
Still,
"the problem with sonar is that
there are
usually multiple
occurrences,
that the
animal may
experience
more
than one ping,'' Hastings
said, adding that
tests now under
way on dolphins
in California
should
provide a
more
detailed understanding.
Another
ongoing study involves tagging different
animals
with tracking
devices that allow
scientists to get
a better
idea of their behavior
patterns. Duke's
Read is also working
on a Navy-funded
project to
synthesize
statistics
on
marine mammal location
and behavior into
a model that's
able to
predict the animals'
habitats
at specific
times.
Still,
high costs, the secrecy surrounding
the technology
and difficulties
testing federally
protected
animals in
natural settings have
turned basic research
into a major
challenge.
"The
science is very much in its infancy,''
NOAA's
Spradlin said.
Looking
for Gift Ideas? Give A Dolphin World Gift Certificate!
To get your Dolphin World
Gift Certificate:
- Go to our online
reservation page.
- Once on the online reservation
page, pick the program you would like give as a gift.
- Fill
out the reservation form, like a normal reservation.
- Once
you come to the comment section, please put Gift Certificate
and any special instructions
you might have.
Your
Dolphin World vacation package will be sent to you
immediately for you to give as a gift. No better gift
for the true Dolphin lover than a Dolphin World vacation
workshop.
Get
a FREE Dolphin Photo and/or Dolphin Tee Shirt

Place
this link on your personal or business website to receive a
Dolphin Photo FREE.
| Dolphin
Swim / Dolphin
World - Your complete Swim with Dolphin website,
Dolphin Swim vacations, Dolphin retail store, Dolphin give
away contest and much more. |
Get A FREE 8"X10" Dolphin
Photo
Place this Dolphin World
link on your personal or business web site and we will you send you ONE
(1) 8"X10" Glossy Print Photo of Dolphins, a $10.95 value
FREE to you. You must submit via email, info@dolphinworld.org your
name, address and where you placed the link.
Plus, Get A $25 Coupon
for a Dolphin Swim
Place a Dolphin World Banner
on your personal or business web site and we will you send you a Dolphin
World coupon worth $25. You must submit via email, info@dolphinworld.org your
name, address and where you placed the Banner.
Link Placement Instructions
To add a link to your site, click
here for more information. Thank you for placing one of Dolphin
World's link on your website!! We will reciprocate a link back to
you if you have Florida, Dolphin, Marine Animal related website, please
let us know.
// TOP \\
TropicalAdventure.com
Fishing
Costa Rica
The
Captain is known for his almost 100% hit rate, even after twelve
years in business. Guests can be assured, Captain Tom has brought
together a high level crew, with years of experience, including First
Mate R.J. Lilly, and 2nd mate, Douglas Martinez Serrano. Together,
they have provided countless numbers of enthusiastic travelers a
chance to catch the big fish of the Pacific coast.
To find out more about this story, please read this article on TropicalAdventure.com.
If you are outdoor lover, this would be a great trip for you. Read
More!!
Win
FREE Dolphin Swims Plus Snorkel Trip, Sunset Cruise Plus More From
TropicalAdventure.com!

Click
here to enter
See if you are the WINNER of last month!
Click
Here
// TOP \\
More Dolphin Photos
Visit
DolphinWorld.org to
see some incredible Dolphin images (Go!) |